Peer Review Process

All manuscripts submitted to Tarbiyah: Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan dan Pengajaran undergo a double-blind peer review, where the identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential to maintain objectivity and academic integrity.

Editorial Process Step-by-Step

  1. Submission: Authors submit their manuscripts via the submission system.
  2. Editor Screening: Editors check for completeness, topic relevance, and initial quality.
  3. Peer Review: At least two independent reviewers evaluate the quality, originality, methodology, and relevance of the manuscript.
  4. Revision: Authors respond to reviewers' comments and make requested improvements.
  5. Acceptance: Editors make the final decision based on reviewers' recommendations.
  6. Publication: Manuscripts are published openly in the journal.

APC Note:

Article Processing Charges (APC) of IDR 200,000 are only paid after a manuscript is accepted for publication. No submission fees are charged. Full details are available on the Publication Fees page.

Reviewer Criteria and Recruitment

Reviewers are recruited through an open online form (GForm), with academic qualifications and experience in education. Each manuscript is reviewed by a minimum of two independent reviewers.

Timeline and Communication

The target review time is approximately 7–14 days, depending on manuscript complexity. Editors communicate with reviewers and authors via official email or legitimate instant messaging to ensure a smooth review process.

Security and Integrity

All manuscripts are checked with Turnitin for plagiarism detection, but results are used internally by the editorial team only and are not made public.

Reviewer Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers are required to declare any potential conflicts of interest, whether academic, financial, or personal, and must recuse themselves from reviewing affected manuscripts. Editors ensure that the review process remains fair and unbiased.

Transparency, fairness, and academic quality are the top priorities in our peer review process. Further information about publication ethics is available at Publication Ethics.

Related Policies:

Last updated: 1 February 2026